headermask image

header image

The Indian Wireless Carrier War - What it means for Indian Mobile Startups:

I just got back from a 6 week long business trip in Bangalore, India. I got myself an AirTel card the day that I arrived and got down to doing some work at our ThoughtWorks Bangalore Office. If you go down to India - you cannot miss it - there really is a pitched battle being fought by carriers in almost all of the major towns and cities across India. The winner at this point undoubtedly is the Indian wireless consumer.

Telecom service providers in the United States face an enormous battle. In wireless, the days of double-digit market growth in the America’s is over, leaving competitors to fight for one another’s customers - government regulations that allow subscribers to shift their numbers make this an almost existential problem. Not surprisingly, share prices in the sector have tumbled from their highs in 2000, but even today’s depressed prices are hard to justify without much-improved margins.

In India however, the feverish competition between carriers has not had an adverse effect on bottomlines. The reason for this is simple - The top 3 carriers in the country are connecting 1M NEW* subscribers a month. This I would imagine helps them to continue with their primary focus which is to protect and increase their turf. They are not interested in focusing on the Value Added Service part of their offerings to increase their user base - they can barely complete the paper work to get their new customers signed up every month - this is a good problem to have if you are an Asian Carrier but if you’re a start-up in India trying to get a deal with the carriers to increase your customer base and widen your distribution channel - I have 2 words for you - Wake Up!

A recent report by In-Stat found the following:

* The total number of new subscribers in 2004-2009 is expected to be 777.7 million worldwide.
* While China continues to lead the world in overall subscriber growth, the percentage growth leaders continue to be found in other parts of Asia, particularly the Southern Asia region that includes India. Nearly two-thirds of all new wireless users will be in Asia.
* European subscriber growth will continue to slow, and will stall in Scandinavia and Western Europe.
* Japan’s rapid transition to 3G accounts for a great deal of the WCDMA growth in the short term.

This is a trend we will be seeing in the near future - though it seems like a grey cloud over many Indian wireless startups, there is a silver lining which basically indicates that value added services are HOT in developed markets while still in their infancy in developing regions (most notably India).

Mobile startups in India should focus their product offerings to be globally relevant in the near term while developing more relevant content for different regions this will allow Indian startups to attract an international audience that is willing to pay today while the carriers focus on their turf war which will settle just like it did in the US in the next 3-4 yrs.

* this was mentioned to me during a chat with an official from one of the leading carriers in India.

If you liked my post, feel free to subscribe to my rss feeds

6 Comments so far (Add 1 more)

  1. I think a reality dose is needed. VAS is doing well in India and is not all that bleak as it sounds. It may not be a significant number compared to the voice revenue but all operators are focusing on increasing VAS revenues experimenting with MMS, GPRS applications, etc. The key they are trying to crack is the mass consumer application which is not more than 6-12 months away.

    1. hussain on December 4th, 2006 at 6:22 am
  2. That would mean a 3 years of gestation period for the mobile VAS startups. Not a bad deal i would say. It takes that much time to convince the operators anyways! The mobile VAS startups being formed right now would be at the right place at the right time then. Explains why the mobile VAS segment is so hot nowadays for the VC’s.

    2. Rajiv on November 16th, 2006 at 7:02 am
  3. Nice post!
    I didn’t know you work in TW these days. Your ideas exactly match the conclusion I and my friends reached when evaluating ideas for startup. Great minds think alike? ;-)

    3. Ravi Mohan on November 15th, 2006 at 1:31 am
  4. Rajiv,

    Indian carriers are a strange bunch - on the one hand they have this total disregard for VAS (today) and on the other they are leading the way in experimenting with new technologies in GSM (see the GSM conference highlights recently) - the latest Windows Mobile + HP offering with inbuilt GPS capabilities (for Indian Roads) is an example - however, I do feel that their marketing and distribution channels will take to VAS only after the next 2-3 years.

    Until then I think we will see some carriers gain an upper hand while some of the smaller players will get acquired leaving only 2-4 top carriers that will then focus on increasing ARPU per customer.

    4. kiran on November 14th, 2006 at 1:10 pm
  5. Good point! Right now VAS is not the foucs and the content has to be really compelling for the operator to buy it. But on the other side ARPU is on the decline and there will be a time when they will have to look at VAS services to keep up the double digit growth.

    When do you think will Indian market reach that phase? 2 years, 5 years, 10 years!!!

    5. Rajiv on November 14th, 2006 at 5:24 am
  6. The operators in India are on a high at the moment with subscriptions clocking more then 1million a month. Like the internet boom in in 1998.. its now the mobile boom which is going to create lot of start up companies and as a result will create some giants like Yahoo ! Google ! in the mobile space.

    The opportunity in India is huge and myself being from the Telecom industry with experience in starting my own VAS Start up company. There is a huge opportunity in VAS in India and once 3G is launched in 2008 there will be even more opportunity. Right now the major VAS related content is mainly SMS based, Digital Music like Ringtones, Ringback tones, Wallpapers, TV based interactive content on SMS.

    6. Sidhartha Bezbora on November 9th, 2006 at 4:32 am

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *

*
*